Thursday, June 12, 2008

Christianity: practice or belief system?

Christianity: practice or belief system

Brian McLaren was featured in an interesting interview on the FERMI Project podcast discussing his new book, Finding Our Way: The Return of the Ancient Practices. I picked up a copy last week but haven’t finished it yet. At the beginning of chapter one, he tells about interviewing Peter Senge at a pastor’s conference. McLaren opened the interview by acknowledging for Senge that the audience of pastors was probably different than his usual gatherings of business leaders. Senge replied,

“Well, Brian, you’re right. I don’t normally speak to pastors. Actually, I was thinking about that very question yesterday when I was in a large bookstore. I asked the bookstore manager what the most popular books are these days. Most popular, he said, were books about how to get rich in the new information economy, which didn’t surprise me. …Second most popular, the manager said were books about spirituality, and in particular, books about Buddhism. And so when I thought about speaking to five hundred Christian pastors today, I thought I’d begin by asking you all a question: why are books on Buddhism so popular, and not books on Christianity?” (McLaren, Finding Our Way, p.3)

McLaren returned the question to Senge, “How would you answer that question?” Senge’s answer was, I believe, profound and very intriguing:

“I think it’s because Buddhism presents itself as a way of life, and Christianity presents itself as a system of belief. So I would want to get Christian ministers thinking about how to rediscover their own faith as a way of life, because that’s what people are searching for today. That’s what they need most.”

This was a wonderful statement for me personally because it speaks very pointedly to my own faith context at this particular time of my life. (I alluded to this in a blog post a couple of months ago). I have found my received Christianity-as-belief-system increasingly problematic as I move through my life. The fact that this belief system began 44 years ago as an extremely fundamentalist and literal form of Christianity has had much to do with my discontent. It simply could not bare the weight of life and circumstances and I found I could no longer ignore the empirical evidence of life lived outside the bubble of Christendom. And yet, I couldn’t leave “the church” or faith or Jesus.

Several weeks ago, I attended a 5 Day Academy for Spiritual Formation. To be perfectly honest, I began the experience extremely cynical and with very low expectations. I left that experience with a profound new understanding of my own faith journey and of my practice of faith from that point forward. Specifically, my new understanding revolves around this tension between practice and system of belief. I would love to hear some of your thoughts on this.

Wednesday, June 4, 2008

Book Review: "Centering Prayer and Inner Awakening"

Cynthia Bourgeault, Centering Prayer and Inner Awakening, foreward by Thomas Keating (Cambridge: Cowley Publications, 2004). 178 pp.

Although centering prayer has caught on in many Christian circles, seminaries, and churches since the 1970s, there is much confusion as to how one goes about doing centering prayer and how it is grounded in Christian theology and history. So when my spiritual director recommended Cynthia Bourgeault's, Centering Prayer and Inner Awakening, I thought that it was just going to be another lofty and esoteric book on prayer in general. I had read Nouwen, Merton, and several other masters on prayer; why read another one?

As I started reading Bourgeault's very accessible and user-friendly book during a silent retreat, I discovered just how important this book really is. For one, Bourgeault does not allow readers to get bogged down in either the history or the theology of centering prayer. Rather, she thrusts her readers right into the practice of centering prayer. She makes no apologies: to get the hang of centering prayer, you must make the effort to do it on a regular basis!

The first section (of four) is appropriately titled, "The Method of Centering Prayer." She instructs readers as the practice and nuances of centering prayer by defining centering prayer and then declaring what it is not. This is important because many Christians (Baptists especially) assume that centering prayer is simply New Age or Buddhist meditation in disguise. Christian centering prayer is not rooted in the east, but is rooted in Jewish rabbinic and mystic tradition. Even Jesus declares in Matthew that when one prays, one should go into a prayer closet to pray to God in "secret." Also, Jesus time and again sought solitude as a forum for building and maintaining his relationship with the Father. Prayer of a similar fashion has also been popularized by such Protestant authors as Henry Blackeby in Experiencing God, although his prescription of prayer is far removed than the intent of centering prayer.

Bourgeault insists that true centering prayer is uniquely Christian and grounded in historic Christian theology because it is a type of prayer that aims at reaching into the very heart of God not to get a word from God or a spiritual insight, but to simply rest in quality intimacy with God. Whereas eastern religions seek to empty the soul/mind or to push thoughts that erupt during meditation aside, centering prayer provides space for thoughts and the imagination to work, but recognizes that one must surrender these thoughts before God. The mind is not occupied by these thoughts or distractions. Instead, the pray-er surrenders thoughts to God and refocuses the heart on spending quality time with the Lord. In this way, true centering prayer allows the believer to "take every thought captive before the Lord," but to practice "dying to self" in the process.

She writes: "As a method of meditation, Centering Prayer is founded upon the gesture of surrendering, or letting go . . . During the prayer time itself, surrender is practiced through the letting go of thoughts as they arise. Unlike other forms of meditation, neither focused awareness nor a steady witnessing presence is required. There is no need to 'follow' the thought as they arise; merely to let them go promptly as soon as you realize you're engaged in thinking [is the goal]" (162).

Bourgeault tells one story, originally told by Thomas Keating, of a nun that attempted centering prayer for the first time. The nun was frustrated that she could not concentrate on spending time with the Lord in silence. In the midst of her solitude, she was bombarded by her many concerns and worries. She told Keating that in twenty minutes, she had ten thousand thoughts. Keating was overjoyed, for he believed that she had ten thousand opportunities to return to the Lord!

Returning to the Lord in solitude and silence is the key to centering prayer. To help one "return to the Lord", Bourgeault recommends having a "prayer word" that one uses to remind oneself that they are spending time with God, not being distracted. A prayer word, be it "love" or "God" or "Abba," acts like a red string tied around your finger. Whenever you find yourself wandering in your thoughts during prayer, reciting silently your prayer word will help refocus your heart upon God.

Centering Prayer and Inner Awakening has been one of the most user-friendly guides I have read concerning centering prayer. For all of the questions that I had about prayer, Bourgeault has managed to answer almost every one of them. I highly recommend that you invest in this book if you are interested in truly seeking God in both solitude and silence.